Brooks B17
Top PickWhat We Like
- Leather hammock flexes over rough roads
- Classic looks suit steel and touring bikes
- Steel rails and leather build feel planted
Worth Noting
- 0.53 kg is heavy for a road build
- Cover
- Full-grain leather
- Rails
- Steel
- Length
- 275 mm
- Weight
- 1.17 lb
Read the full review
The B17 is the saddle we recommend with a caveat: give it time. The full-grain leather top starts firm and takes a while to form to you, and the steel rails and 275 mm length give it a classic, planted feel. The leather is the reason to choose it, and the shape has earned its following. It is a shape that has been around for a reason, and it still makes sense for a certain kind of road bike.
Once it started to give, we understood the appeal. The leather hammock flexes over bumps, the shape supports a long, upright road position, and the finish looks right on a steel or classic bike. It also needs proofide and a little weather sense, which is more upkeep than the rubber Cambium asks for. The B17 is not a saddle for a race fit.
We recommend the B17 for long-distance riders who want a leather hammock and will put in the break-in time. It is a saddle that gets better with use, and the steel rails and leather top feel solid under a loaded bike. If you want the same classic look without the maintenance, the Cambium is the easier choice. It is a long-term saddle, not an instant upgrade.
Bottom line: The B17 rewards long-distance riders who want a leather hammock and are willing to put in the break-in time.